The Issue of Health Care: Obama or Romney?

The winds of hurricane Sandy have stopped blowing here in NYC but we now anticipate the winds of change that will surely rain down upon us on Election Day.  I'm not going to choose the side of either Obama or Romney, especially since this election seems to be more about voting against the guy we don't like rather than really galvanizing behind one capable and confidence-inspiring candidate.  Let's restrict this conversation to an issue near and dear to me and my patients - health care.  And my apologies at the outset, this is about the problems. If I had a solution I would run for office or join a think tank, or write a book, or something.

The Problems:

We are a nation of 300 million people, and aging.  Health care may or may not be an inalienable right, but as the land of the free it would be nice to imagine that every citizen is entitled to the same level of skilled, quality health care.  But it is exceedingly difficult to deliver quality accessible care at a reasonable cost.  Currently health care costs consume 17.9% of the GDP of the US, by far the highest percentage of any country in the world.

This country has the potential to deliver great health care.  We have some of the best doctors, hospitals and research institutions in the world.  A patient with good insurance and a savvy knowledge of the system can receive cutting edge treatment for just about any disease, common or rare.  However delivering unlimited care to everyone, especially end of life care, and care of chronic and complex disease and trauma, is very expensive.  Consider that the top 10% of Medicare recipients by expenditure received 64% of the medicare dollars in 2009.

And let's think about a few generic, but specific scenarios:

The solutions?

I wish.  Is universal health care the answer?  In England, everyone is covered, but accessibility is an issue and wait times for physicians and hospitals are far longer than here in America.  In Israel, government sponsored health care is the norm, but many drugs and diagnostic tests are simply not covered.  Our fee for service system rewards those who treat the sick, perform procedures and order many diagnostic tests.  Doctors order unnecessary tests to guard against legal action.  There are many hospitals, each of which requires many patients to maintain a profitable bottom line.  Young physicians are compelled to enter specialties that are more lucrative in order to pay off an average of $250,000 in student loan debt.  And a private health insurance system is mired in administrative costs and CEO bonuses.

Any solution is going to require sacrifice on the part of doctors, patients and hospitals.  Tort reform, universal health care, student loan subsidies, and a reform of the health insurance industry are all potentially good starting points.  One thing is for certain, our current system is unsustainable.  Our country owes its citizens better, and we can formulate a workable solution for everyone, I think.  If anyone has one, let me know, maybe I'll vote for you.

See you in the office.

Dr. Ernest L. Isaacson

Author
Ernest Isaacson Dr. Ernest Isaacson is a graduate of the Scholl College of Podiatric Medicine at Rosalind Franklin University of Medicine and Science. After completing two years of comprehensive training in various medical specialties including internal medicine, general surgery, orthopedic surgery, vascular surgery, plastic surgery and podiatric medicine, Dr. Isaacson completed a comprehensive one-year podiatric surgical residency. Dr. Isaacson is active in research and publication in basic and clinical science. Dr. Isaacson is also a dedicated family man who enjoys running, reading and spending time with his family.

You Might Also Enjoy...

When Should I Get Bunion Surgery?

Here’s a question I get pretty often: why feet?  And I answer, because I love feet. And usually I’ll add a comment about how it’s a good thing I’m not a gastroenterologist or a urologist or something along those lines.

Heal the Heel

Ok kids time for a little word association. Tell me the first thing you think of when I say - plantar fasciitis. If it starts with an F no need to articulate the sentiment, but you might want to read on.

And I Thank You

Shocking, yet not surprising, the year is coming to a close and it’s already time to shop bargains on turkey and squash.

Why You Should Call Your Podiatrist (even after hours)

It’s relatively late at night in the city as I write this, and many of my dear Manhattan podiatry patients may be wondering what it is I’m doing at this late hour, other than filling the annals of this most holy and sacred blog with more consecrated verbia

Heal Thyself

Summer’s over now kids, although if you’re like me summer is just winter with heat. Still, I do get a little pit in my stomach as Labor Day looms large on the calendar and the waning days of summer transform into the crisp breezes of autumn, and other line